California Testing Out Gas Tax Alternative with Pay-Per-Mile Program

By: Sam Watanuki | Published: May 22, 2024

As California sees a rise in electric vehicles, the state’s gas tax revenue, crucial for road maintenance, is decreasing.

Caltrans is testing the California Road Charge, a pilot program that could replace gas taxes with a pay-per-mile system. This innovative approach addresses the urgent need for sustainable road funding.

Pilot Program Details

Starting in June 2024, participants in the six-month pilot will track their miles using various methods, including electronic devices or simple odometer photos.

Advertisement
A Tesla Model 3 in motion on a curvy forest road during rainy weather, showcasing the vehicle's sleek design and dynamic handling

Source: Tesla/X

They will be compensated up to $400 and have their gas tax fees waived, offering a direct incentive to participate.

Addressing Privacy Concerns

Privacy is a significant concern with mileage tracking. Lauren Prehoda from the Road Charge Program assures that Caltrans will only see the number of miles and not specific location information.

Advertisement
Website code being seen through an artisitic lense.

Source: Markus Spiske/Unsplash

This is to ensure participants’ privacy while collecting necessary data.

Reaction from EV Owners

Electric vehicle owners are wary. Jamonique Fletcher, an EV owner, shared concerns about the new system impacting EV benefits.

Advertisement
Several cars in different colors are parked in front of a row of Tesla super chargers on a rainy day

Source: Cnyor/Wikipedia Commons

“I would be very upset because I think it just kind of retracts the incentive that they were trying to get people to purchase electric vehicles,” Fletcher said.

Economic Forecast

Prehoda also highlights the pressing economic challenge: within 10 years, the state could face a $4.4 billion shortfall due to decreasing gas tax revenue.

Advertisement
An image of the price of gas at a Chevron gas station

Source: Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

This pilot program is racing against time to find a solution before this forecast turns into a major crisis.

How to Participate

Californians interested in joining the pilot can sign up through the California Road Charge website.

A silver and black car parked in a lot hooked up to a large black portable charging station

Source: @AnonOffGrid/X

The program seeks to attract a diverse pool of participants, essential for testing the system’s effectiveness across various demographics and vehicle types.

Advertisement

Varied Charging Strategies

Participants in the pilot will experience different charging methods.

A silver car parked on the street is hooked up to an electric charging port

Source: Ernest Ojeh/Unsplash

Some will pay a flat rate, while others’ fees will depend on their vehicle’s fuel efficiency, aiming to equitably distribute the tax burden based on usage.

Advertisement

Legislative Decisions Ahead

The pilot’s results will play a critical role in legislative decisions.

Close-up of a wooden gavel on its sound block, placed on a dark surface with a soft-focus background

Source: Sora Shimazaki/Pexels

It’s up to the California Legislature to decide if this road charge should replace the gas tax permanently, shaping the future of state infrastructure funding.

Advertisement

Stabilizing Road Maintenance Funding

The shift to a mileage tax aims to stabilize funding for road maintenance as gas tax revenues decline.

Two construction workers in high visibility vests and hard hats are walking on a dirt path at a construction site

Source: Wikimedia Commons

This change is crucial for maintaining California’s extensive road network in the face of evolving automotive technologies.

Advertisement

Data Management and Privacy

Offering options from low-tech to high-tech for tracking mileage, Caltrans ensures that participants can choose their comfort level with data sharing.

An image of a man working on data and figures at his desk

Source: Freepik

“It’s really important to have options,” says Prehoda, emphasizing the balance between data efficiency and privacy.

Advertisement

Pilot Program Feedback

Throughout the pilot, feedback from participants will be vital.

A Tesla EV charging station with just one car in the lot

Source: Wikipedia

Caltrans will use this data to refine the program, ensuring it meets the needs of California drivers before any statewide rollout.

Advertisement

A National Trendsetter

California’s pilot program could set a precedent for other states.

A shot of the LA skyline on a nice day. Multiple palm trees take up the view of the foreground

Source: shalunts/Getty Images

This particular experiment might become a model for how to fund road maintenance in the era of electric vehicles and reduced gas consumption.

Advertisement